August 31, 2000

MEMORANDUM TO: OPINION LEADERS

FROM: WILLIAM KRISTOL

SUBJECT: Defense

"We reversed the declines that began in the Bush-Quayle years."
Vice President Al Gore, August 30, 2000
responding to Dick Cheney on military preparedness.

Nonsense. The Clinton-Gore Administration deepened and extended the post-Cold War defense cuts begun by the Bush Administration; Clinton and Gore argued that the Bush-Quayle reductions were not deep enough, and acted accordingly. In particular, Clinton and Gore:

• Doubled the size of the cuts in defense spending, ignoring their own pledges from the 1992 campaign, thus causing defense budgets to fall to their lowest level as a measure of GDP since before World War II;

• Reduced the active-duty armed forces by an additional 200,000 personnel beyond the Bush "Base Force" plan;

• Permitted unit combat readiness rates to fall significantly across all services;

• Extended the defense "procurement holiday," failing until this year to meet the minimum weapons spending levels recommended by the Joint Chiefs of Staff (and then this year only by ignoring inflation and by accounting legerdemain).

Indeed, the Clinton-Gore Administration has repeatedly complained about the Republican Congress adding "money the Pentagon does not need" to the defense budget. Clinton’s promise of Pentagon budget increases in the “outyears,” Gore's deathbed conversion to the cause of defense preparedness and Gore’s own plan for increased defense spending are all a tacit admission of the deleterious effects of the Clinton years.

A yawning gap now exists between America's responsibility to lead the world and its declining ability to project global military power. There are deficiencies in the arguments George Bush and Dick Cheney have made with respect to foreign and defense policy. But this claim by Al Gore is Clintonian in its disregard for the truth.