December 19, 2000

MEMORANDUM TO: OPINION LEADERS

FROM: TOM DONNELLY, Deputy Director

SUBJECT: Quadrennial Defense Review

One of the prime tasks for the incoming Bush Administration will be to oversee the conduct of the second Quadrennial Defense Review, the document that outlines U.S. military strategy and sets forth the plans and programs to execute that strategy. To make the 2001 QDR a success, it is essential that the Pentagon define the defense of Taiwan as its central scenario for potential major theater conflicts.

The Taiwan scenario is crucially important for two reasons. The first is that China now looms as the single most likely and most powerful “strategic competitor” - to use President-elect Bush’s term - to the United States in the coming decades. Gen. Henry H. Shelton, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, revealed Pentagon thinking on the issue last week when he described Beijing as a potential “21st-century Soviet Union,” driven by aggressive policies and embarked upon an ambitious program of military modernization.

The Defense Department must begin now to seriously contemplate the implications of a future conflict over Taiwan. Indeed, this may be the best way to prevent such a conflict from occurring.

The second reason is that defending Taiwan would require very different kinds of forces than those needed for the large-war scenarios of past defense reviews: a war on the Korean peninsula or another Iraqi invasion of Kuwait. Although both those scenarios remain valid measures of U.S. military capabilities, a future Taiwan conflict would increase the importance of new kinds of forces, notably those capable of long-range precision strikes and defense against ballistic missile attack. Defending Taiwan will require a significant transformation of current U.S. force structure. China’s recent defense “white paper” makes it clear that the People’s Liberation Army wishes to exploit new technologies to threaten Taiwan; the upcoming QDR must take these developments into account.